Devanagari
यथेमेऽविकृता भावास्तथा ते विकृतै: सह ।
नानावीर्या: पृथग्भूता विराजं जनयन्ति हि ॥ १५ ॥
सन्निपत्य समुत्पाद्य दृश्यन्तेऽनुगता इव ।
प्रागेव विद्यमानत्वान्न तेषामिह सम्भव: ॥ १६ ॥
एवं भवान् बुद्ध्यनुमेयलक्षणै-
र्ग्राह्यैर्गुणै: सन्नपि तद्गुणाग्रह: ।
अनावृतत्वाद् बहिरन्तरं न ते
सर्वस्य सर्वात्मन आत्मवस्तुन: ॥ १७ ॥
Verse text
yatheme ’vikṛtā bhāvās
tathā te vikṛtaiḥ saha
nānā-vīryāḥ pṛthag-bhūtā
virājaṁ janayanti hi
sannipatya samutpādya
dṛśyante ’nugatā iva
prāg eva vidyamānatvān
na teṣām iha sambhavaḥ
evaṁ bhavān buddhy-anumeya-lakṣaṇair
grāhyair guṇaiḥ sann api tad-guṇāgrahaḥ
anāvṛtatvād bahir antaraṁ na te
sarvasya sarvātmana ātma-vastunaḥ
Synonyms
yathā
—
as
;
ime
—
these material creations, made of material energy
;
avikṛtāḥ
—
actually not disintegrated
;
bhāvāḥ
—
with such a conception
;
tathā
—
similarly
;
te
—
they
;
vikṛtaiḥ saha
—
association with these different elements coming from the total material energy
;
nānā
—
vīryāḥ — every element is full of different energies
;
pṛthak
—
separated
;
bhūtāḥ
—
becoming
;
virājam
—
the whole cosmic manifestation
;
janayanti
—
create
;
hi
—
indeed
;
sannipatya
—
because of association with the spiritual energy
;
samutpādya
—
after being created
;
dṛśyante
—
they appear
;
anugatāḥ
—
entered within it
;
iva
—
as if
;
prāk
—
from the very beginning, before the creation of this cosmic manifestation
;
eva
—
indeed
;
vidyamānatvāt
—
due to the existence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead
;
na
—
not
;
teṣām
—
of these material elements
;
iha
—
in this matter of creation
;
sambhavaḥ
—
entering would have been possible
;
evam
—
in this way
;
bhavān
—
O my Lord
;
buddhi
—
anumeya — lakṣaṇaiḥ — by real intelligence and by such symptoms
;
grāhyaiḥ
—
with the objects of the senses
;
guṇaiḥ
—
with the modes of material nature
;
san api
—
although in touch
;
tat
—
guṇa — agrahaḥ — are not touched by the material qualities
;
anāvṛtatvāt
—
because of being situated everywhere
;
bahiḥ antaram
—
within the external and internal
;
na te
—
there is no such thing for You
;
sarvasya
—
of everything
;
sarva
—
ātmanaḥ — You are the root of everything
;
ātma
—
vastunaḥ — everything belongs to You, but You are outside and inside of everything .
Translation
The mahat-tattva, the total material energy, is undivided, but because of the material modes of nature, it appears to separate into earth, water, fire, air and ether. Because of the living energy [jīva-bhūta], these separated energies combine to make the cosmic manifestation visible, but in fact, before the creation of the cosmos, the total energy is already present. Therefore, the total material energy never actually enters the creation. Similarly, although You are perceived by our senses because of Your presence, You cannot be perceived by the senses, nor experienced by the mind or words [avāṅ-mānasa-gocara]. With our senses we can perceive some things, but not everything; for example, we can use our eyes to see, but not to taste. Consequently, You are beyond perception by the senses. Although in touch with the modes of material nature, You are unaffected by them. You are the prime factor in everything, the all-pervading, undivided Supersoul. For You, therefore, there is no external or internal. You never entered the womb of Devakī; rather, You existed there already.
Translation (Visvanatha Cakravarti Thakura)
The mahat-tattva, the total material energy, is undivided, but because of the material modes of nature, it appears to separate into earth, water, fire, air and ether. Because of the living energy [jīva-bhūta], these separated energies combine to make the cosmic manifestation visible, but in fact, before the creation of the cosmos, the total energy is already present. Therefore, the total material energy never actually enters the creation. Similarly, although You are perceived by our senses because of Your presence, You cannot be perceived by the senses, nor experienced by the mind or words [avāṅ-mānasa-gocara]. With our senses we can perceive some things, but not everything; for example, we can use our eyes to see, but not to taste. Consequently, You are beyond perception by the senses. Although in touch with the modes of material nature, You are unaffected by them. You are the prime factor in everything, the all-pervading, undivided Supersoul. For You, therefore, there is no external or internal. You never entered the womb of Devakī; rather, You existed there already.
KB 10.3.15-18
One may argue that the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who creates the whole cosmic manifestation simply by His glance, cannot come within the womb of Devakī, the wife of Vasudeva. To eradicate this argument, Vasudeva said, “My dear Lord, it is not a very wonderful thing that You have appeared within the womb of Devakī, because the creation was also made in that way. You were lying in the Causal Ocean as Mahā-Viṣṇu, and by Your breathing process, innumerable universes came into existence. Then You entered into each of the universes as Garbhodakaśāyī Viṣṇu. Then again You expanded Yourself as Kṣīrodakaśāyī Viṣṇu and entered into the hearts of all living entities and even within the atoms. Therefore Your entrance into the womb of Devakī is understandable in the same way. You appear to have entered, but You are simultaneously all-pervading. We can understand Your entrance and nonentrance from material examples. The total material energy remains intact even after being divided into sixteen elements. The material body is nothing but the combination of the five gross elements—namely earth, water, fire, air and ether. Whenever there is a material body, it appears that such elements are newly created, but actually the elements are always existing outside of the body. Similarly, although You have appeared as a child in the womb of Devakī, You are also existing outside. You are always in Your abode, but still You can simultaneously expand Yourself into millions of forms.
“One has to understand Your appearance with great intelligence because the material energy is also emanating from You. You are the original source of the material energy, just as the sun is the source of the sunshine. The sunshine cannot cover the sun globe, nor can the material energy—being an emanation from You—cover You. You appear to be in the three modes of material energy, but actually the three modes of material energy cannot cover You. This is understood by the highly intellectual philosophers. In other words, although You appear to be within the material energy, You are never covered by it.”
We hear from the Vedic version that the Supreme Brahman exhibits His effulgence and therefore everything becomes illuminated. We can understand from the Brahma-saṁhitā that the brahma-jyoti, or the Brahman effulgence, emanates from the body of the Supreme Lord. And from the Brahman effulgence, all creation takes place. It is also stated in the Bhagavad-gītā that the Lord is the support of the Brahman effulgence. Therefore, originally He is the root cause of everything. But persons who are less intelligent think that when the Supreme Personality of Godhead comes within this material world He accepts the material qualities. Such conclusions are not very mature but are made by the less intelligent.
The Supreme Personality of Godhead is directly and indirectly existing everywhere; He is outside this material creation, and He is also within it. He is within this material creation not only as Garbhodakaśāyī Viṣṇu; He is also within the atom. The existence of the atom is due to His presence. Nothing can be separated from His existence. In the Vedic injunctions we find that the Supreme Soul, or the root cause of everything, has to be searched out because nothing exists independently of the Supreme Soul. Therefore the material manifestation is also a transformation of His potency. Both inert matter and the living force—the soul—are emanations from Him. Only the foolish conclude that when the Supreme Lord appears He accepts the conditions of matter. Even if He appears to have accepted a material body, He is still not subjected to any material condition. Kṛṣṇa has therefore appeared and defeated all imperfect conclusions about the appearance and disappearance of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.
Purport
This same understanding is explained by the Lord Himself in
Bhagavad-gītā
(9.4)
:
mayā tatam idaṁ sarvaṁ
jagad-avyakta-mūrtinā
mat-sthāni sarva-bhūtāni
na cāhaṁ teṣv avasthitaḥ
“By Me, in My unmanifested form, this entire universe is pervaded. All beings are in Me, but I am not in them.”
The Supreme Personality of Godhead is not perceivable through the gross material senses. It is said that Lord Śrī Kṛṣṇa’s name, fame, pastimes, etc., cannot be understood by material senses. Only to one who is engaged in pure devotional service under proper guidance is He revealed. As stated in
Brahma-saṁhitā
(5.38)
:
premāṣjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena
santaḥ sadaiva hṛdayeṣu vilokayanti
One can see the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Govinda, always, within oneself and outside oneself, if one has developed the transcendental loving attitude toward Him. Thus for people in general, He is not visible. In the above-mentioned verse from
Bhagavad-gītā,
therefore, it is said that although He is all-pervading, everywhere present, He is not conceivable by the material senses. But actually, although we cannot see Him, everything is resting in Him. As discussed in the Seventh Chapter of
Bhagavad-gītā,
the entire material cosmic manifestation is only a combination of His two different energies, the superior, spiritual energy and the inferior, material energy. Just as the sunshine is spread all over the universe, the energy of the Lord is spread all over the creation, and everything is resting in that energy.
Yet one should not conclude that because He is spread all over He has lost His personal existence. To refute such arguments, the Lord says, “I am everywhere, and everything is in Me, but still I am aloof.” For example, a king heads a government which is but the manifestation of the king’s energy; the different governmental departments are nothing but the energies of the king, and each department is resting on the king’s power. But still one cannot expect the king to be present in every department personally. That is a crude example. Similarly, all the manifestations that we see, and everything that exists, both in this material world and in the spiritual world, are resting on the energy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The creation takes place by the diffusion of His different energies, and, as stated in the
Bhagavad-gītā,
He is everywhere present by His personal representation, the diffusion of His different energies.
One may argue that the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who creates the whole cosmic manifestation simply by His glance, cannot come within the womb of Devakī, the wife of Vasudeva. To eradicate this argument, Vasudeva said, “My dear Lord, it is not very wonderful that You appeared within the womb of Devakī, for the creation was also made in that way. You were lying in the Causal Ocean as Mahā-Viṣṇu, and by Your breathing, innumerable universes came into existence. Then You entered into each of the universes as Garbhodakaśāyī Viṣṇu. Then again You expanded Yourself as Kṣīrodakaśāyī Viṣṇu and entered into the heart of all living entities and entered even within the atoms. Therefore Your entrance into the womb of Devakī is understandable in the same way. You appear to have entered, but You are simultaneously all-pervading. We can understand Your entrance and nonentrance from material examples. The total material energy remains intact even after being divided into sixteen elements. The material body is nothing but a combination of the five gross elements — namely earth, water, fire, air and ether. Whenever there is a material body, it appears that such elements are newly created, but actually the elements are always existing outside of the body. Similarly, although You appear as a child in the womb of Devakī, You are also existing outside. You are always in Your abode, but still You can simultaneously expand Yourself into millions of forms.
“One has to understand Your appearance with great intelligence because the material energy is also emanating from You. You are the original source of the material energy, just as the sun is the source of the sunshine. The sunshine cannot cover the sun globe, nor can the material energy — being an emanation from You — cover You. You appear to be in the three modes of material energy, but actually the three modes of material energy cannot cover You. This is understood by the highly intellectual philosophers. In other words, although You appear to be within the material energy, You are never covered by it.”
We hear from the Vedic version that the Supreme Brahman exhibits His effulgence and therefore everything is illuminated. We can understand from
Brahma-saṁhitā
that the
brahmajyoti,
or the Brahman effulgence, emanates from the body of the Supreme Lord. And from the Brahman effulgence, all creation takes place. It is further stated in the
Bhagavad-gītā
that the Lord is the support of the Brahman effulgence. Originally He is the root cause of everything. But persons who are less intelligent think that when the Supreme Personality of Godhead comes within this material world, He accepts material qualities. Such conclusions are not mature, but are made by the less intelligent.
Purport (Visvanatha Cakravarti Thakura)
This verse gives an example. You enter into Devaki’s womb just like the undifferentiated mahat tattva and other elements (ime) enter the universe but do not enter it, or appear to be created but actually are not. Though you appear to be born, you are not. The maha tattva, possessing within it various distinct elements such as earth, joining with consciousness, creates the material universe. Though the elements appear to have entered into the creation (anugata iva), because they remain present outside as well, one cannot say they have entered. Though they appear to arise within the universe, they actually existed before the universe.
The elements are touched by the gunas , but you as the supreme cause are not touched by the gunas, though you enter into the universe. Though you are perceived as full of qualities which can be perceived by the intelligence, you, full of bliss, do not accept the qualities of matter, whose essence is suffering. Why? Because you are not covered by the gunas of matter. Those who are covered by the material gunas take up those qualities. The gunas do not contaminate you internally or externally. The jiva however, contacts the objects of sound and touch externally, and internally experiences lamentation, and illusion. Not only you , pervading everywhere as Paramatma (sarvatmanah), but also all objects related to you in the spiritual world (atma vastunah), such as the devotee, dhama and pastimes, are untouched by matter.
Purport (Jiva Goswami)
Though you seemed to have entered mahat-tattva and other elements it is impossible. This is explained in two verses. Entering means that a person outside enters within. Since the elements already existed as the cause (with effect inherent in them) and simply manifest as the effect within the universe, they really do not enter.
Since you are the supreme cause, you also do not enter or touch the universe. Thus, though you have this nature, when you enter, it is your great mercy. Śrīdhara Svāmī explains this. Guṇaiḥ can mean “with qualities” or “with objects.” You exist with qualities such as being under the control of prema. You have attraction to such qualities. These qualities can be inferred by intelligence but not realized. Na tat-samaś cābhyadhikaś ca dṛśyate: the Lord has no equal or superior. (Śvetāśvatāra Upaniṣad) Why can we not understand you? You are everything (sarvasya). You are the giver of consciousness to all beings or you spread everywhere (savrātmanaḥ). You exist by yourself. You are the highest goal which appears by itself (ātma-vastunaḥ). Therefore you are constantly filled with unlimited qualities since you are always controlled by the prema of your devotees (tad-guṇāgraḥ). Thus you have appeared as our son. This is the greatest result for us.
Purport (Sanatana Goswami)
You do not enter the elements or, though you do not enter, you enter. An example is given. This is explained in two verses. Because at first mahat-tattva and other elements were the cause, and existed separately as coverings, they do not enter the universe (iha), though they seem to enter.
The total material energy is undivided, but because of various potencies it appears as separate elements. Combining together, the elements produce the universe.
Or though the energy is undivided, by manifesting your (te) māyā-śakti (tathā), the various elements produce the universe. Or because the elements exist separately, by an inconceivable method (tathā), they do not enter the universe. Or for many births I have known your glories. But today I have become successful. Starting in verse 13, Vasudeva explains. For many lives I have directly known you as most worthy of worship. This he explains in three lines. I have become successful because you have entered Devakī’s womb, though you are beyond prakṛti. His entering Devakī is further described in verses 15-16.